Thursday, October 11, 2018

General D'Armee - Vittoria scenario played

Game at Stephens today and he chose to try GDA with a scenario based on Vittoria battle 1813 with his British force against my French.

Good game although the 'dice demon' was yet again on fine fettle.
He claimed not to be that lucky then rolled 6 hits out of 6 immediately afterwards, proof irrefutable says I !!

Once again we found a lot to like with these rules especially the charging and melee outcome charts, very flavoursome and easy to use.
I love the Brigade Skirmisher system.

But as always seems to occur with GDA we ran into a couple of situations where we struggled to find a definitive or at least an unambiguous answer.
Main one was regarding Skirmish units firing, with one rule clearly stating that skirmishers can choose to shoot a multiple targets at players discretion however on opposite page it gives a Skirmish Priority rules which seems to contradict the previous rule seemingly making skirmishers split their fire at any (all ??) target in arc.
We were not sure how one can have Priority Targets if able to select a chosen target ?
We simply could not reconcile these two rule entries eventually deciding that splitting fire seemed better simulation of skirmisher activity than allowing these extended formations from possibly concentrating on a single target.
But we are unsure what rules intent is ?

Artillery is pretty potent in GDA and the Faltering rules are brutal as a Brigade Falters when one unit is Dispersed or two Retreated.
Certainly leads to decisive outcomes in games.

Personally I like the rules overall but sometimes feel they are too slow/intricate compared with FOB, Shako or Black Powder but that might be down to interpretation frustrations and lack of familiarity with systems.








French left








French center (nice new 'Spanish' buildings from Empires At War range)









French right








British right









Central British deployment








British gun battery that caused a lot of hurt









French right with Artillery Brigade hoping to pound the town








Both forces arrayed









French advance on left









Skirmishers clash on right










Skirmishers and Chasseurs pushed back on French left








AS British Infantry counter attacks at bayonet point








Reserve French Brigade moves on town









French right Falters as a Veteran Legere unit dispersed





4 comments:

  1. Well even if the rules have ambiguity, your table does not. It is beautiful!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I will probably have to pick up these rules at some point. It seems to me like a
    Strong point is that you can see all the elements taking place, but that the same aspect also slows things down compared with a more top down approach like FoB.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Certainly FOB allows much bigger games to play to completion in reasonable time. GDA has a bit more of an attritional combat model but once Brigades Falter they can prove tough to recover. There are rules to cover Multi Corps games and suchlike but we have played Divisional/ small Corps games. For me its strength is its modelling of Charges and Melees. I would rate it a tad more complex (involved might be more apt) than FOB but not onerously so.

      Delete